Christmas Trifle with Jelly, Custard and Peaches

A make-ahead Christmas trifle with sponge, red jelly, peaches, vanilla custard and whipped cream. Includes an alcohol-free option and staged chilling.

Prep: 30 minutes (plus jelly cooling and at least 8 hours chilling) Cook: No cooking (apart from kettle water for jelly) Servings: 8 people
Watercolour illustration of Christmas trifle with sponge, red jelly, peaches, yellow custard and whipped cream topped with almond flakes in a glass bowl.

Ingredients

Have your ingredients ready? Go to instructions
Measures: 1 tbsp = 15ml; 1 tsp = 5ml. For local ingredient names and substitutions, see our guide to Maltese ingredients abroad.

Instructions

  1. Prepare the jelly: Make 500ml jelly according to its packet, dissolving it fully with the specified boiling water before adding the cold water. Leave to cool until just lukewarm and still liquid. Use a jug or bowl suited to hot liquid.
  2. Layer the base: Use a clean glass serving bowl of at least 2.5 litres. Spread the sponge pieces lightly with jam and arrange in the base. Drizzle with the sherry or reserved peach juice. Scatter the drained peaches over the sponge.
  3. Set the jelly: Pour the cooled liquid jelly gently over the sponge and fruit. Cover and refrigerate for at least 6 hours, or until completely set; follow the packet if it specifies a longer setting time. Do not add custard while the jelly is liquid.
  4. Add custard: Spoon the cold thick custard over the fully set base and spread gently into an even layer. Keep refrigerated while preparing the cream.
  5. Top with cream: Whip the cold cream with the icing sugar until it holds soft peaks. Spoon over the custard without pressing down. Cover without touching the topping and chill for at least another 2 hours.
  6. Finish and serve: Scatter the optional cooled almond flakes over just before serving. Spoon down through all the layers for each portion and return the remaining trifle to the fridge promptly.

Trifle is a shared British-influenced dessert also made in Malta. This version layers sponge, fruit jelly, peaches, thick custard and whipped cream in one glass bowl. It is a make-ahead option for a Christmas table rather than a uniquely Maltese formula.

Start the Day Before

Allow at least eight hours of refrigeration, in two stages, plus time for the freshly made jelly to cool. Overnight setting of the sponge-and-jelly layer is convenient; add the custard and cream the next morning and chill again before lunch.

Use a bowl of at least 2.5 litres that fits in the fridge. Check the jelly packet by its prepared volume, since sachet weights vary. This recipe needs 500ml of finished jelly, not 500ml water in addition to a packet’s full instructions.

Keep the Layers Separate

Choose a thick, spoonable ready-made custard. Thin pouring custard will give a softer layer and may run into the fruit. Chill it before assembly. If using homemade custard instead, cook it fully, cool promptly and refrigerate before adding it; do not pour it warm onto the jelly.

Drain the peaches well so the jelly is not diluted with extra juice. Canned peaches are straightforward here; fresh pineapple, kiwi and papaya can stop gelatine jelly setting properly and should not replace them directly.

Alcohol and Ingredient Choices

Reserved peach juice replaces the sherry measure for measure. Check purchased sponge, custard and jelly against your guests’ needs: wheat, eggs and dairy are common, and many jellies contain animal gelatine. For a vegetarian table, choose a suitable setting product and follow its own preparation and setting instructions. The optional almond topping can be omitted.

Serving and Keeping

Keep the trifle covered in the fridge at 5°C or below until serving. Assemble with freshly opened custard and cream, and eat within 48 hours of beginning assembly, or sooner if an ingredient label requires it. Do not leave the bowl out for a long buffet; serve portions and return it to the fridge. Freezing spoils the texture of the jelly and cream, so make only the quantity you need.

Trifle on a Maltese Festive Table

Malta’s Primary HealthCare Christmas recipe booklet includes little trifle treats, and Scotts publishes a fruit trifle. These show the dessert in local cooking; the peach, jelly and custard combination here uses its own quantities and method. Chilling guidance follows the Food Standards Agency.

Plan the other courses with the Maltese Christmas food collection.